in ,

What To Make Of Vern Cotter’s Final Six Nations Squad

We’ve looked at Vern Cotter’s Scotland’s squad announcement to figure out what it tells us about the state of the nation and what the likely team will be for the opening Ireland test.

Scotland’s head coach Vern Cotter during the 6 Nations Squad…

Scotland’s head coach Vern Cotter during the 6 Nations Squad Announcement at Murrayfield, Edinburgh. Get premium, high resolution news photos at Getty Images

The team has changed drastically under Cotter

It’s clear from his selections that outgoing coach Cotter has resisted the urge to throw caution to the wind in the naming of his final squad, instead opting for a settled group that he will no doubt be hoping can deliver something of a swansong before his unceremonious replacement by Gregor Townsend.

In many ways, this squad is a testament to the work he has done over his time in charge and shows just how far the team has come. Only 15 players remain from Scott Johnson’s 2014 Six Nations squad, and Cotter has capped a staggering 26 players in his 3 short years in charge (a number likely to grow before tournament’s end).

John Hardie was parachuted in to great effect by Cotter

You just need to look at some of the player he debuted who have subsequently become household names – guys like Finn Russell, Mark Bennett, Zander Fagerson, John Hardie, Huw Jones, WP Nel, Josh Strauss, Hamish Watson, and Ali Price – to see how much depth he has added.

Nowhere is this depth more apparent that the embarrassment of riches in the centres. The fact that he’s taken the unusual step of naming 5 just goes to show how competitive selection has become in what was once Scotland’s problem position (what former coach Frank Hadden would have given for just 1 of them!).

There is also very clear strength in the backrow with any number of possible combinations from the 7 players picked. It would take a brave soul to bet on the exact makeup of the matchday 3, let alone the numbers each will wear on their back.

The addition of Cornell du Preez also adds something very different to the mix. The South African born fan favourite offers ball playing skills that none of the others possess. Whilst he’s faced injury and form problems this season, if he gets a chance to show what he can do then he has the potential to really turn heads during this tournament.

Cornell Du Preez of Edinburgh offloads under pressure from Shane…

Cornell Du Preez of Edinburgh offloads under pressure from Shane Geraghty of London Irish during the European Rugby Challenge Cup match between London Irish and Edinburgh Rugby at Madejski Stadium on… Get premium, high resolution news photos at Getty Images

Du Preez looked very impressive against Quins

The back three pretty much picks itself (Hogg and Seymour), with the only toss up being between Maitland and Visser. It is also worth noting what Cotter said about Huw Jones and Taylor being versatile. Could this see them move to wing or fullback if needed? It would certainly be a good way of getting some extra ball players into the side. All of which may make it difficult for Hoyland to add to his solitary 2 caps.

You’ve got to say it’s tough for Blair Kinghorn, but the extra centre means someone had to be cut from the back three. His time will come.

As ever, there are only two shades of Grey in the second row, but big Ben Toolis has been on fine form and will no doubt see his chance come. Behind them the drop off is a little more pronounced. Grant Gilchrist has been struggling to get back up to speed since his ridiculously long injury layoff, but would never let the side down should he be called upon. 

Tim Swinson, whilst an excellent club player for Glasgow, has failed to impress at international level and may be considered lucky to feature ahead of Edinburgh’s resurgent Fraser McKenzie.

Rob Harley of Glasgow Warriors claims the lineout during the Guinness…

Rob Harley of Glasgow Warriors claims the lineout during the Guinness PRO12 Round 5 match between Newport Gwent Dragons and Glasgow Warriors at Rodney Parade on September 30, 2016 in Newport, Wales. Get premium, high resolution news photos at Getty Images

Bob Harley can cover both the back and 2nd row

There’s also the possibility of Rob Harley packing down in the middle, especially as a super sub, but the fact that he’s been named in the back row would imply Cotter has plans for him there.

The front row is also looking stronger than ever with Dell and Fagerson the incumbent props sandwiching either Ford or Brown. That said, it is a real concern to be without Cotter’s first choice props Dickinson and Nel, however there’s still hope that they will feature at some point in the Championship. Few would have expected to see Jon Welsh back in the blue jersey and Reid has struggled to find the form of his breakthrough season, so they will need at least one of Nel and Dickinson back fighting fit sooner rather than later.

Welsh bring these silky smooth skills to the front row

That’s not to say that there aren’t weaknesses in this squad. Whilst a very able kicker and safe pair of hands, it must be said that Duncan Weir represents a pretty big step down from Finn Russell at 10. If the dancer goes off for any reason, the whole backline will have to change style dramatically to suit the Edinburgh man’s more conservative style. Had Jackson been getting more starts at Quins or Horne not been injured, you suspect Cotter would have preferred their more similar styles.

Scrum half, whilst not an acute issue, could cause concern as the tournament wears on. Cotter has show time and again that he likes to have opposing styles starting and on the bench to offer something different in the closing stages. As team captain and goal kicker, Greig Laidlaw is almost certain to start every game, but his delivery is famously ponderous and can at times slow down the exciting backline.

Ali Price of Glasgow Warriors breaks free of the Munster defence…

Ali Price of Glasgow Warriors breaks free of the Munster defence during the European Rugby Champions Cup match between Glasgow Warriors and Munster Rugby at Scotstoun Stadium on January 14, 2017 in… Get premium, high resolution news photos at Getty Images

Price has been running riot this season

Ali Price is clearly included as the foil, but his inexperience was evident last weekend against Munster when he and Russell spurned a pop at a match winning drop goal. Russell plays best when he has a scrum half who can take some of the decision making burden but, whilst very exciting with ball in hand, it’s it could be argued that Price isn’t quite there yet.

Which leaves Henry Pyrgos, a man who has barely touched the ball in months. As a result he’s looked a little out of form since his return and, whilst Hart, Hidalgo Clyne and Kennedy have failed to set the heather alight, he may consider himself quite lucky to be included. 

So which players from those 37 will make the matchday squad for the opening clash against Ireland? I’ll take a punt at this team, although the centres and backrow may well be drastically different.

1: Allan Dell

2: Ross Ford

3: Zander Fagerson

4: Richie Gray

5: Jonny Gray

6: John Barclay

7: Hamish Watson

8: Ryan Wilson

9: Greig Laidlaw CAPTAIN

10: Finn Russell

11: Tommy Seymour

12: Alex Dunbar

13: Huw Jones

14: Sean Maitland

15: Stuart Hogg

16: Fraser Brown

17: Alex Allan

18: Simon Berghan

19: Ben Toolis

20: Rob Harley

21: Ali Price

22: Duncan Weir

23: Matt Scott

Who do you think Cotter will pick for the opening game? Let us know in the comments below.

What do you think?


Leave a Reply
    • That was a club game. As the article says, he’s an excellent club player, but has never done anything of note in the blue of Scotland. That’s despite having 25 bites at the cherry. Some players never make the step up from club to country, and at 29 and only 6’5, it looks like Swinson is that kind of guy. But who knows, maybe he’ll come on and have a stormer.

    • Scotland Rugby News I agree to a certain extent, he’s rarely performed at his best on the test stage, although I did think his first few tests in summer 2013 were very promising. But in the article it suggests that he might not be in the matchday 23 and that MacKenzie (I player who is underrated as well) might be ahead of him. I admit I’ve seen limited Edinburgh matches this season, but I think Tim is ahead of their options in the second row currently. We need Gilchrist to show the early form and promise we saw in him, unfortunately he’s had hideous luck with injuries and sickness in his test career.

    • Hahaha “that was a club game” it was a champions cup game against probably the form team in Europe. Granted swinson hasn’t performed as well in international games but I don’t think you could really say that gilchrist or toolis have either

    • Neil I think it would be fair to say that neither of those guys have had the chance. Gilchrist looked very promising but was then crocked for years. I think he’s been included to give him a chance to fulfil that promise, however I wouldn’t have been surprised if he’d been left out. This is very different to Toolis who has had a barnstorming couple of seasons and yet has only got a single opportunity in the thistle! He has to be ahead of Swinson in the pecking order. Were he not injured, and presuming he’d continued his upward trajectory, I would have expected Scott Cummings to have featured.

    • Would put Watson in place of hardie. He plays a stormer every game also hardie can’t get a start for Edinburgh due to this. Would start Wilson over Strauss, granted he’s had a few good performances recently but Wilson is the best forward for Glasgow all season

    • Ruari MacAllister Strauss outplayed CJ Stander last weekend and has had some massive performances lately, agree Watson for Hardie, Hardie I don’t believe is fit and Watson even by his high standards has been excellent recently. I don’t think Jones or Taylor can start, Taylor coming back from injury, Jones no game time since the Argentina test. I think Dunbar and Scott to start, Bennett coming back into some form and looked dangerous, but not quite at his best. Jones on the bench to get in the running against Ireland. I’ve also a horrible suspicion that Nel won’t be ready for Ireland, fortunately Zander has developed leaps and bounds this season and can take that responsibility.

    • With Dell and Allan we have some cover at LH, Zander is our main cover at TH and played well in the autumn tests and has been very solid lately. A useful threat in the loose too. Hopefully we’ll see Nel at some point in the tournament, any word on Sutherland’s injury? He was very good in the summer tour, solid in the set piece and a big carrier in the loose.

  1. Scott in for Dunbar potentially with Scott being on fire recently. Dunbar is a solid defender and hard ball carrier which works well with jones, but he may want two ball players at 12/13 to create the opportunities for Hogg and seymour.

Leave a Reply

Vern Cotter Names His Final Six Nations Scotland Rugby Squad

WP Nel Out Of Six Nations And Doubt For Lions